Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Shoni's avatar

This is what I'm trying to achieve with my novel, Journey to Kyron (as you mention, 'a tale of exploration and discovery, such as space travelers encountering a strange new planet'). Plenty of conflict and human interest in the day-to-day lives of the explorers, but crucially, the reason for the journey is not to escape an ailing Earth, but because the world has become so prosperous that such a journey becomes possible.

Expand full comment
Drew Hoskins's avatar

As an author, the struggle to tone it down is real. I sometimes feel compelled to add dystopian elements to make the setting pop and increase the stakes. Anxieties like "will anybody want to publish/read this?" can drive one to play up the drama.

I'm almost finished with a novel in which there are two (mostly non-dystopian) realities. Their histories diverged for unknown reasons, and one is "us in 2050" and the other is around 150 years behind, tech-wise. (think: dieselpunk).

The mystery is: why?

I've struggled to figure out how dystopian to make each world, because of course one of the questions is, which world would you rather live in? As a technophile, I don't want it to come off as ideological or preachy. And I want to embrace and understand technology wholeheartedly, not just its good parts.

Expand full comment
35 more comments...

No posts